The angst of dismissal

unfair dismissal

No, not the angst of being dismissed but the angst of having to dismiss someone.

I was having a natter this morning, before work, with a chap who runs a business; he was telling me various things and I was telling some of mine.  His first.

He was saying he had a chap working for him long ago, “in the vaults”, whatever that means and this chap did not wash or at least, he did not change his clothes day in, day out.  This was not great for the other staff down there and so he was taken aside and given a polite request to do something about it.

Now, knowing my acquaintance/friend, he would have been charming about it in the first instance and the danger would have been that the smelly one might easily not have taken him seriously.  He ignored the warning, ignored the second warning/ultimatum and then found himself asked to collect his things and go hen he turned up a third time.

This acquaintance/friend is a very nice man, interesting and calm, with a nice smile but when he says something, he means it.  Though I agree with him in principle, I’ve always had trouble dismissing people.  I couldn’t have done one thing he did.

There was a worker who had worked very hard, over and above the call of duty, for some years but it seems he was in a critical position which couldn’t be covered at no notice – we’ll just accept this at face value for now.  He came to work one day in a right state and the story turned out to be that his daughter had lost her pet and was distraught, the mother was too and he said he just had to go home and look after them.

Our employer asked why the mother could not do the comforting until he came home after work.  The man had insisted but our employer had insisted back that the man was in a critical position and couldn’t be replaced before the morrow, that there was the wife to do the comforting and so our employer had no recourse but to refuse the request.  The man went on about how he’d worked over and above etc., which had been true but our employer asked him to go and have a tea or coffee and consider his position.

The man said he was going anyway and the employer said that if he went through that door, it would be for the last time.

Harsh?  I’ve been thinking about that and as usual, can see both sides.

My worst one was also my first and it was to dismiss a former colleague as my first act.  The grounds were not conduct, unfortunately but efficiency and there really was no choice.  What made it worse was that she wasn’t complying with new government requirements, requirements which I did not even personally support.  My position was closer to hers in education.

Yet she wouldn’t, couldn’t budge and so it was done, with the resultant bad scene, stretched over weeks.  It had been a long time coming  but still, when the moment came, it took a lot of something – courage?  No.  Chutzpah?  Maybe.  Bloodymindedness?  Possibly.  Coldness?  I fear so.

The other side of the employment fence can sometimes be almost as difficult.

8 Responses to “The angst of dismissal”

  1. I’ve been a manager and had to sack people often enough. It wasn’t a problem for seasonal hires as it was expected, it was the normal, long term employees that were most difficult.

    I never become friendly with the boss to spare both of us the added stress if I become redundant and get sacked.


  2. If it helps, all the other workers think you bosses are w*****s!

    No offence.


  3. Unfortunately the sacking of people is necessary in business. It is not something I would like to be responsible for.


  4. Dickhead should have just said he was sick and not turned up. Honesty is never the best policy nowadays.

    Sacking people is usually the hardest part of the job. Sometimes it is not though. It depends.


  5. Digested, folks.


  6. My worst-ever day at work: having to call in two of my guys who’d just come in for night-shift, and tell them they were being got rid of. Of course, as soon as I called them, they knew what was coming – but that didn’t make it any easier.

    What a shite evening that was, I can remember it still. I suppose it was worse for them, at least I still had a job the next morning.

    Being the boss is definitely not easy – “nobody said it would be easy”.


  7. I was always happy that I did not have to do human resource type stuff and just had to get on with my job.


  8. Sadly, there’s a mentality, esp. in HR, of little people letting it go to their heads. A good leader though would suffer inside whenever he/she had to do this.